Article

MSc scriptie - Middle class neighbourhood belonging in Overtoomse Veld, Amsterdam and Peckham, London

This thesis looks to understand how the middle-class practice neighbourhood belonging in two different neighbourhoods. It shows how middle-class neighbourhood belonging is based on practicing attachment to certain characteristics of the neighbourhood and disaffiliation to others. Through practicing belonging, the middle-class also shape the neighbourhood through inscribing meaning onto the space. This affects what power that neighbourhood holds in the urban hierahy and contributes to the politics of belonging at the neighbourhood scale by determining who belongs where, and for what reasons. My research looked to explain the middle-class belonging of middle-class young professional in two relatively marginalised and ethnically diverse neighbourhoods – Overtoomse Veld (OV) in Amsterdam and Queens Road Peckham in London. I used a Bourdieusian framework which defines neighbourhood belonging as a congruence between habitus and field. I found that:

A) Living around people of the same age, class, tenure and subsequently the same lifestyle strengthens a sense of neighbourhood belonging.

B) The residential choice of my middle-class respondents’ affects their neighbourhood belonging.

C) In Peckham, I found that neighbourhood belonging is the strongest for those whose bourgeois-bohemian habitus matches the cultural field of Peckham. The same bourgeois-bohemians are also diversity-seekers and have a stronger sense of engagement with the ethnic diversity of the neighbourhood than those with a more traditional middle-class identity. Those who are more traditionally middle-class practice more disaffiliation socially and spatially from the ethnic or classed ‘others’.

D) In both cases, belonging to either middle-class faction (bourgeois-bohemian or traditional middle-class) is explained, in part, through a development of their habitus linked to their spatial and social trajectory.

E) In Overtoomse Veld, I found that a lack of middle-class youth presence in the neighbourhood detracted from a sense of belonging. A lack of amenities catering for middle-class cultural consumption in the neighbourhood meant that the neighbourhood had mostly a practical function rather than a symbolic function. In OV, the width of social difference in terms of class and ethnicity between the middle-class newcomers and the long-term residents, practiced in the neighbourhood and influenced by national discourses of immigration, weakened a sense of neighbourhood belonging.

 

Student: William Stuttard

Additional info